Fallacy Finder

Dedicated fallacy page

Fallacy Library Nirvana Fallacy
Informal fallacy

Nirvana Fallacy

Rejects a realistic option because it is not perfect, comparing it unfairly to an idealized alternative.

Definition

Rejects a realistic option because it is not perfect, comparing it unfairly to an idealized alternative.

Example
Because no transportation system can eliminate accidents entirely, there is no point in improving road safety.
Extended explanation

How to think about it:

Rejects a realistic option because it is not perfect, comparing it unfairly to an idealized alternative. In practice, the key question is whether the conclusion is supported by evidence and logic, or whether it depends on this reasoning shortcut instead.

Related entries

Related by logic, rhetoric, or real-world co-occurrence

These suggestions are ranked using a hybrid score that combines curated links, shared families, wording similarity, and any saved-analysis pairings the app has observed.